Individual Entry

Brass Knuckle Blogs



Useful Links









Add to Technorati Favorites

[Valid RSS]

NucleusCMS
Nucleus CMS v3.24



template by i-marco's choice

Dynamic Drive

Valid XHTML 1.0 Transitional
Valid CSS


Shock And Shame

by: Debra

No awe. Our military is stretched too thin, flailing uselessly in a country that is in the midst of imploding. Currently there are several units preparing to return to Iraq for the third time, like it's going to make a difference. Meanwhile the Pentagon is considering writing off the Anbar province and moving the marines to Baghdad which is tantamount to defeat. On several levels.

The draft, while evenly distributing the pain of loss across most economic levels, is not the answer. Neither is contracting out to private companies for the day to day running of the military (at a greater expense to the taxpayer) or having almost 30,000 immigrant soldiers (almost 2% of the military willing to die for a chance at citizenship) but that has been our solution. War is no longer a matter of honor and citizenship, it is a financial decision. From the war mongerers to the lowly private.

This creates several issues, not the least of which is a mercenary army whose loyalty will not be to the United States of America but to the almighty dollar, such as it may be. Serving in the military will become the poor person's only option for improving their life. Provided they survive whatever conflict that the war profiteers have deemed necessary for that decade.

Of course we could always supplement active duty military with the Reserves and the National Guard. Oops, we did that already. What to do, what to do? The cynic in me says the most expedient solution is to go back to that idea of selling citizenship for military service. If they are willing to die to live here so real Americans don't have to, why not? Umm, because it's wrong?

This begs the question, why would someone be willing to die for a country where the citizens don't care enough to participate by backing up their words with actions? It's not like veterans are held in high regard after their usefulness has passed. Why would you want to take the chance of dying for a country that starts a war and then blames the victims for not doing more to make it a success?

In war the only flowers are the ones on the graves of the service members who died in vain. Death doesn't care if you are a citizen or trying to provide for your family.

Crossposted at the usual place.

2 comments:

Gaius Marius, in his efforts to save the Roman Republic from threats by German tribes, then Jugurtha in North Africa, did away with the citizenship and landowning requirements for service in Rome's legions. He began enlisting the head count. He began to hire foreign auxiliaries with the promise of Roman citizenship. It was the beginning of the end of the very republic he was trying to save. It was Roman auxilliary troops that began the "Italian Rights" civil war, which ended in Sulla marching on Rome itself and installing himself as dictator. It carried through Caesar, who made senators of Gauls and Belgians.

I don't know whether or not conscription is the way to go. I do know that under the "all volunteer" format our military has become far more insulated, isolated and more subject to executive whims. I'm with Driftglass on this one. I am not sure how I feel about the issue. I am a total process junkie. We need a wide ranging, free wheeling debate on this issue.
by: Minstrel Boy (contact) - 29 Nov '06 - 09:48
I believe in a volunteer army during peacetime. If we are attacked and have to defend our home turf, recruiters won't be needed. The problem has been that the last few conflicts have not been moral or just and therefore only those who need the money are willing to take the chance of dying for no good reason.

Fighting them over there so we don't have to fight them over here is just not a good enough reason for most people to die. They might support the idea but not enough to physically participate.

Driftglass' article was insightful and accurate.
by: Debra (contact) - 29 Nov '06 - 10:02



This item is closed, it's not possible to add new comments to it or to vote on it
«Return to the Main Page of Big Brass Blog

Meta Information:

Title: Shock And Shame
Date posted: 29 Nov '06 - 00:59
No Trackbacks
Filed under: Military
Good Karma: 4 (vote)
Bad Karma: 1 (vote)
Next entry: » Major Overhaul of US Currency Overdue
Previous entry: « In The Corners of My Mind

Frontpage
:
:

Navigation

  Today
  Archives
  Contact

Calendar

Search


Blog Headlines

Advertisements

Dark Wraith's Bookstore

♦           ♦           ♦
Free Sound Effects
Download Free Sound Effects from AudioMicro.
♦           ♦           ♦

News

Diversions

In the News

Quote of the Day